7 Reasons to Choose Paying Out-of-Pocket for Therapy

Photo by Engin Akyurt | Pexels

The health insurance industry has been under intense scrutiny lately, with major players like UnitedHealthcare facing criticism for flaws that negatively impact patients across the country. Issues like denied claims, endless red tape, and a system that often prioritizes cost-cutting over patient care are at the forefront of these concerns.

Maybe you've heard about a major study from late 2023 that got people talking. It found that nearly 20% of insurance claims are denied on the first submission, with denial rates even higher for mental health and emergency services. More alarming reports suggest that 30-40% of private insurance claims are denied, highlighting the challenges patients face when navigating insurance systems. Instead of focusing on their health, patients are left to navigate frustrating appeals processes, which rarely lead to successful resolutions. If you weren’t stressed before having to deal with insurance denials, red tape, and all these issues, now you definitely are—yet another problem that requires care!

These challenges are especially pronounced when it comes to accessing mental health care, which often presents additional barriers. But what if there was a better way to access the mental health care you deserve? If you're considering therapy or counseling, let's explore some reasons why choosing to pay out of pocket might be the better option for you.

1. Freedom from the Medical Model and Diagnostic Labels

Insurance companies require therapists to assign a clinical diagnosis to justify payment. While a formal diagnosis is necessary for certain conditions, it may feel restrictive if your therapy goals focus on personal growth rather than managing a specific disorder. Want to work primarily on building self-esteem, managing stress, or gaining clarity on your life’s direction? These issues can be harder to get covered by insurance, as they may not meet the "medical necessity" criteria, even though they are crucial to your overall well-being.

Paying privately means therapy can focus entirely on you, not just your diagnosis. Sessions can be designed around your unique goals and aspirations, providing a space for personal growth without the constraints of a label. It’s a space where you can embrace your individual strengths and nuances, knowing you are more than just a diagnosis.

2. Full Control Over Your Therapy Schedule

Insurance companies love to micromanage therapy—setting arbitrary limits on session length, frequency, or duration. For example, some insurers might approve only a handful of sessions at a time or restrict session length to 45 minutes, which can be a real challenge sometimes. Whether you’re “the talker” type who needs time to get everything off your chest, or the “slow to warm up” type, needing to go at your own pace (you know, not really getting to the good stuff until about 40 minutes in), it’s hard to fully process everything when you’re suddenly being asked to wrap up. This can disrupt the therapeutic process, forcing therapists and clients to rush or compromise on the depth of care.

When choosing self-pay, you decide how long, how often, and how much support you need—free from a third party’s oversight. You might schedule more frequent sessions, like twice a week, during a particularly challenging period, and then transition to weekly, bi-weekly, or monthly check-ins as you progress, all without needing external approval.

Photo by Engin Akyurt | Pexels

3. Supporting Ethical, High-Quality Care for Your Therapist

Insurance companies are notorious for underpaying therapists, which can lead to burnout and less personalized care. For example, BCBS is often criticized by therapists for its below-market reimbursement rates, particularly in certain markets (Uhm... Did someone say Texas?). This not only limits the pool of qualified therapists who accept insurance, but also affects the quality of care you receive.

When you pay privately, you’re:

• Supporting High-Quality Care: Therapists have more time and energy to dedicate to each client, which usually results in providing the highest quality care.

• Supporting Therapist Well-Being: Therapists can maintain a healthier work-life balance, reducing burnout and allowing them to continue their meaningful work with sustainability and enthusiasm, which is...you know, nice.

• Helping Others: Many private-pay therapists use the flexibility of their practice to offer sliding-scale rates to clients in financial need. By paying out-of-pocket, you’re indirectly helping make therapy more accessible to others.Your investment in therapy doesn’t just benefit you—it uplifts the entire system.

4. Avoid the Stress of Insurance Bureaucracy

Photo by Mikhail Nilov | Pexels

Ever felt like you were doing a full-time job just to get your insurance to cover a single therapy session? It’s exhausting! Navigating insurance for therapy can sometimes feel overwhelming, with the potential for delays, unexpected costs, and additional paperwork. These challenges might discourage some from continuing care, adding stress during an already vulnerable time. Here are a couple of common issues to be aware of:

· Surprise Costs: Unexpected out-of-pocket expenses can arise from sudden changes in coverage, such as an annual deductible resetting, a provider moving out-of-network, (it’s crucial to notify your therapist as soon as you know you’ll be changing plans), or claim denials. These situations can lead to unplanned financial strain.

· Delays in Payment and Added Paperwork: Insurance companies can require additional documentation to justify treatment, either from you or your therapist. If a claim is denied, appealing the decision may take weeks or even months, adding frustration to an already challenging situation. Delays can also happen due to system-wide disruptions. For instance, a cybersecurity breach affected Change Healthcare in early 2024, halting claims processing and benefits verification for months. This left patients and providers scrambling, with some practices facing significant financial losses and even going under due to lost revenue.

Private pay offers consistency and transparency. You’ll know exactly how much your sessions will cost, with no unwelcome surprises or drastic rate changes. This predictability allows you to focus fully on your therapeutic process without added financial uncertainty.

5. Privacy and Confidentiality

Many people don’t realize that signing up for an insurance plan involves agreeing to share certain personal health information (PHI) with the insurance company as part of the coverage contract—it’s all in the fine print. Although HIPAA restricts the use of this information to specific purposes, such as coordinating benefits or making coverage decisions, some find the idea of sharing deeply personal details with a third party uncomfortable or even invasive.

In certain situations, having a mental health diagnosis on record could raise concerns or lead to unintended consequences. For example, individuals involved in a child custody dispute or working in specific sensitive professions may want to maintain stricter privacy around their mental health information. Even minor details in these records could be misinterpreted or used in ways that impact legal outcomes or job prospects.

Opting to pay out-of-pocket adds an extra layer of protection and confidentiality over your mental health records, as your therapy stays strictly between you and your therapist. This can provide peace of mind in circumstances where privacy is especially important.

Photo by Kindel Media | Pexels

6. Flexibility in Choosing the Right Therapist

Searching for a therapist can feel like looking for a soulmate or a best friend. There might be limited options, mismatched values, and maybe even a few red flags. Many therapists don’t accept insurance due to the low reimbursement rates and administrative burden. As a result, relying solely on in-network providers could mean missing out on a therapist who is the perfect fit for your needs.

Going the self-pay route allows you to choose a therapist based on their experience, specialization, and style—not just their insurance affiliations. It’s like picking out exactly what you want from a catalog—whether you're looking for a therapist with a specific expertise or one whose style resonates with your personality. This expanded pool of options means having more flexibility and freedom to find someone who truly aligns with your needs and is the best equipped to help you achieve your goals.

7. Investing in Yourself to Prioritize Your Mental Health

While private pay isn’t accessible for everyone, it’s worth considering the value of investing in yourself. For many people, therapy is one of the most meaningful investments they can make. And let’s be honest: When we pay more for something, we often value it more—it’s just human nature.

Free or low-cost therapy options can unintentionally make it easier to delay life changes or place less urgency on fully committing to the process. In contrast, making a significant financial commitment can serve as added motivation to fully engage in therapy and apply what you learn to your life.

If cost is a concern, consider using HSA or FSA accounts, which let you pay for therapy using pre-tax dollars. Investing in your mental health is an investment in yourself—one that creates lasting, positive ripple effects throughout every aspect of your life.

Final Thoughts

When it comes to therapy, insurance has its place, but private pay offers some unique benefits, like greater freedom, flexibility, and a more personalized approach. It can also be the better option if privacy, transparency, or simplicity are important to you. Some people are more than willing to pay a premium to avoid navigating the insurance maze.

If you’re curious about your options or feel uncertain about the process, don’t hesitate to reach out. I’m here to help you navigate these decisions and find what’s best for your unique needs. Ultimately, the decision is personal. You deserve to make the choice that best aligns with your needs and values.

For those whose primary concern is the cost of therapy, I invite you to check out another blog I wrote where I discuss several ways to access free or low-cost mental health support.

If you’d like to explore your options or have any questions, feel free to reach out—I'm here to help you find the best path forward.

by Maria Perdomo-Torres, LCSW-S, MHA, CFSW