Should I Stay or Should I Go? What Your Nervous System Might Be Trying to Tell You

Photo by Alena Carmel | Pexels

You’ve had the conversations, and maybe even the arguments. The issues are not new. Maybe it’s emotional unavailability, different values, or a dynamic that leaves you feeling dismissed, anxious, or misunderstood.

Some days, you feel hopeful, like maybe things are finally shifting. But then it happens again, and you feel stuck, resentful, or emotionally drained. And beneath it all, there’s that lingering question you can’t seem to shake:

Should I keep trying, or should I walk away?

You might go back and forth in your mind, weighing pros and cons, trying to figure out whether you’re wasting your time by prolonging the inevitable, or whether you’ll regret letting go if you never find something better.

You might feel guilt, self-doubt, or fear that you’re asking for too much. And you keep hoping that something will finally click into place so you don’t have to make such a hard choice.

If you’ve been stuck in this loop, you know how exhausting it can be. When your heart, mind, and body all feel pulled in different directions. It’s one of the most common (and most emotionally painful) places to be.

You want clarity. You want a sign.
But what’s often misunderstood is why it can feel so impossible to choose.

We tend to assume the conflict is all about the relationship:

• Maybe the other person needs to change.

• Maybe you need to compromise more.

• Maybe you’re just being too sensitive… or not sensitive enough.

While those things might be true, there’s often a deeper reason why it feels so hard to choose: Your nervous system may not yet have the capacity to hold the weight of either option. What keeps people stuck in this kind of emotional limbo isn’t just the relationship itself. It’s the internal overwhelm that comes with facing either decision.

That overwhelm lives in the nervous system.

Understanding the Nervous System’s Role in Relationship Decisions

Our nervous system is designed to protect us from danger… physical and emotional. When it senses threat or discomfort, it shifts into survival mode: fight, flight, freeze, or fawn.

Here’s what that can look like when you’re in relationship limbo:

• Fight: You argue, pick apart your partner’s flaws, or lash out, trying to gain control and create a sense of security.

• Flight: You avoid the hard conversations, stay busy, scroll endlessly, or fantasize about escaping.

• Freeze: You feel numb or disconnected. You keep things status quo to avoid rocking the boat.

• Fawn: You silence your needs and over-accommodate, trying to gain approval, keep the peace, and feel safe in the relationship.

These are not just behaviors. They’re nervous system responses. And when your window of tolerance is narrow, even the thought of making a big decision can feel dangerous to your brain and body.

Photo by Timur Weber | Pexels

The Fork in the Road

Eventually, most people in emotionally conflicted relationships arrive at a fork:

Option A: Stay

This path means accepting some of the things that may never change. It involves grieving unmet expectations, letting go of perfection, and leaning into tools like emotional regulation, boundaries, and deeper communication.

It might require building tolerance for ambiguity, disappointment, or imperfection. This option often means learning to feel safe and adapt to what is, while still showing up for yourself.

Option B: Leave

This road brings its own emotional storms: grief, fear of loneliness, guilt, financial or logistical uncertainty. It may trigger attachment wounds or stories of failure. It takes courage and a willingness to face the unknown.

And here’s what usually happens:

You wait for Option C.

The one where your partner suddenly changes. The communication issues resolve themselves. The relationship becomes everything you hoped it would be… with no hard decisions, no grief, no letting go.

But Option C is rarely real. It’s often a form of emotional avoidance, a nervous system strategy to delay discomfort.

You stay in limbo, hoping instead of deciding, because either direction feels too overwhelming to bear.

Why Nervous System Regulation Is the Missing Piece

What most people need before they can choose is not more logic or more analyzing (there’s usually already plenty of that). What they need is more regulation.

Without nervous system safety, both staying and leaving can feel threatening. You end up circling the same thoughts for months (or even years) without taking action.

Photo by Mikhail Nilov | Pexels

But as you begin to grow your capacity to hold difficult emotions, the fog starts to clear.

This is known as expanding your window of tolerance: the ability to stay present and grounded in the face of strong emotions without becoming overwhelmed or shutting down.

When your nervous system feels safer, you become more able to:

• Notice your emotions without being hijacked by them

• Make decisions from a place of clarity rather than fear

• Grieve what needs to be grieved—whether that’s lost time, unmet dreams, or the fantasy of who someone could become

• Choose with intention, even if the choice is painful

Building the Capacity to Choose

Here are a few ways to support nervous system regulation while navigating relationship indecision:

1. Somatic Grounding Practices

Try movement, breathwork, or sensory tools that help your body feel anchored in the present moment. Even small practices like placing a hand on your chest and exhaling slowly can help signal safety to your system.

2. Name the Inner Conflict

Externalize your thoughts instead of keeping them spinning in your head. Journaling or working with a therapist can help you see more clearly what you're actually afraid of, and what story you might be telling yourself.

3. Acknowledge the Loss Either Way

Whether you stay or leave, there will be grief. Grieving doesn’t mean you made the wrong choice. It means you’re honoring your truth.

4. Stop Waiting for Emotional Certainty

There is rarely a moment where everything feels 100% clear and safe. Sometimes, clarity comes after the decision…not before. Your nervous system might resist change, even when change is what you need.

5. Find Support That Doesn’t Push an Agenda

Not everyone will understand your process. Seek spaces, like therapy or trusted friendships, where you can explore without pressure or judgment.

Photo by Anastasia Shuraeva | Pexels

Choosing from a Regulated Place

You don’t have to figure it all out today. But you do deserve to feel safe enough inside yourself to face the truth, whatever that may be.

Your nervous system isn’t the enemy. It’s trying to protect you. But sometimes the very thing that protects you is the thing that keeps you stuck.

When you begin to feel safe enough to feel discomfort, without numbing, running, or shaming yourself, you create space for clarity to emerge. And from that place, you get to choose. Not because you’re forced. But because you’re ready.

If you're navigating this kind of emotional limbo, you don’t have to do it alone. Therapy can offer a grounded, non-judgmental space to help you reconnect with your inner clarity and nervous system safety.

I’d be honored to walk with you as you sort through what’s real, what’s possible, and what’s next. You can reach out to Graceful Mind Therapy if you’re curious to learn more.

by Maria Perdomo-Torres, LCSW-S, MHA, CFSW